When you’re injured in a crash, your medical bills get paid through different channels. You might use your personal injury protection coverage, your health insurance, Medicare, or Medicaid. Each of these has different rules about whether they can demand reimbursement later. Understanding these rules makes the difference between keeping most of your settlement and watching a large portion disappear to pay back insurers.
What Is Subrogation?
Subrogation gives an insurance company the right to recover money it paid for your medical treatment when someone else caused your injuries. The concept works like this: your health insurer pays your hospital bills after a crash, then steps into your shoes to claim reimbursement from the at-fault driver’s insurance company.
Under Florida law, most health insurance policies include subrogation clauses. When you signed up for coverage, you likely agreed that if someone else injures you and your insurer pays your medical bills, the insurer can seek repayment from any settlement or judgment you receive.
Private health insurance companies pursue these claims aggressively. They track personal injury cases and send lien notices to attorneys, hospitals, and settlement administrators. Medicare and Medicaid have even stronger recovery rights backed by federal statutes. ERISA plans, which cover many employer-provided health benefits, operate under federal law that gives them particularly robust collection powers.
Looking for a Peaceful Legal Resolution? Let Us Help You
Looking for a Peaceful Legal Resolution? Let Us Help You
Get your FREE & confidential case review today
561-689-8180How PIP and Health Insurance Overlap
Florida’s no-fault system adds another layer. Your personal injury protection insurance pays up to $10,000 in medical bills regardless of who caused the accident. PIP kicks in first, before your health insurance.
Here’s where things get complicated. If your medical bills exceed $10,000, your health insurance typically covers the remainder. Both your PIP carrier and your health insurer may claim subrogation rights. PIP carriers in Florida generally cannot seek reimbursement from your bodily injury settlement with the at-fault driver, but they can assert liens in certain situations involving uninsured motorist claims.
Health insurers, on the other hand, almost always assert reimbursement claims. They argue that since another driver caused the accident, they shouldn’t have to pay for treatment that the at-fault party’s liability insurance should cover. This creates a situation where you might receive a $50,000 settlement, only to find out that $30,000 goes to paying back medical bills your health insurer already covered.
The timing matters too. Many people don’t realize their health insurance paid claims until they’re ready to settle their case. The insurer sends a demand letter outlining every payment made and requesting full reimbursement from the settlement proceeds.
Related Reading:
Pre-Existing Conditions & Car Accident Claims in Florida: Know Your Rights
Borrowed Vehicle Liability: Florida’s Dangerous Instrumentality Doctrine Explained
Why Subrogation Matters for Your Net Settlement
A $100,000 settlement sounds significant until you break down where the money goes. Attorney fees typically take 33-40%, depending on whether the case settles or goes to trial. Court costs and case expenses come out next. Then, subrogation liens get paid. What remains is your actual recovery.
Consider a common scenario. You settle for $75,000 after a collision on Southern Boulevard. Your attorney’s fee is $25,000. Medical bills totaled $40,000, and your health insurer paid $32,000 of that. The insurer demands full repayment. Suddenly, your $75,000 settlement leaves you with just $18,000 after paying the attorney and the health insurer.
This becomes even more problematic when injuries are severe, but the available insurance is limited. Florida only requires drivers to carry $10,000 in personal injury protection and doesn’t mandate bodily injury coverage. When you’re hit by someone with minimal insurance, the total settlement might barely cover medical bills and attorney fees, leaving nothing for pain, suffering, or lost wages.
Different Types of Subrogation: Private, Medicaid/Medicare, TRICARE
Not all subrogation claims work the same way. The type of insurance that paid your bills determines how much flexibility exists for negotiation.
Private health insurance companies have contractual subrogation rights based on your policy. These are usually negotiable. An experienced attorney can often reduce these claims by arguing that the insurer should share in the litigation risk and costs. If your settlement doesn’t fully compensate you for all damages, why should the insurer get 100% repayment when you’re not being made whole?
Medicare operates under the Medicare Secondary Payer Act, a federal law that gives Medicare strong recovery rights. When Medicare pays medical bills related to an accident, it expects repayment from any settlement or judgment. Medicare maintains a database of claims and typically sends a demand letter once it learns about a settlement. You cannot ignore Medicare’s claim. Failing to repay Medicare can result in penalties and future claim denials. However, Medicare liens can often be reduced through a process that involves demonstrating your settlement didn’t fully compensate you.
Medicaid recovery rights vary by state. In Florida, the Agency for Health Care Administration handles Medicaid liens. These liens must be addressed before settling a case. Like Medicare, Medicaid has statutory recovery rights, but Florida law includes provisions that can reduce the reimbursement amount, particularly when the settlement doesn’t cover all damages.
TRICARE, the health system for military families, falls under federal law and pursues reimbursement actively. TRICARE liens can be particularly challenging because federal regulations limit negotiation flexibility.
ERISA-governed plans, which include most employer-sponsored health insurance, present unique challenges. These plans operate under federal law that preempts many state consumer protection statutes. Courts have repeatedly held that ERISA plans have powerful reimbursement rights that are difficult to contest.
Looking for a Peaceful Legal Resolution? Let Us Help You
Looking for a Peaceful Legal Resolution? Let Us Help You
Get your FREE & confidential case review todayStrategies to Reduce or Negotiate Reimbursement Claims
You don’t have to accept every subrogation claim at face value. Several strategies can reduce what you owe.
The made-whole doctrine provides that you should be fully compensated for your losses before any subrogation claim gets paid. If your settlement doesn’t cover all your damages, including pain, suffering, lost wages, and future medical costs, then your health insurer should accept a reduced repayment. This argument works better with private insurers than with Medicare or Medicaid, but it’s worth raising in every case.
Proportionate share arguments point out that the insurer didn’t take any risk or incur any costs in pursuing your claim. Your attorney spent time, took depositions, filed motions, and negotiated on your behalf. If your attorney earned one-third of the settlement through that work, shouldn’t the health insurer’s reimbursement be reduced by one-third, too?
Some policies contain language limiting subrogation to amounts recovered after attorney fees and costs. Careful policy review might reveal favorable language that reduces what the insurer can claim.
Challenging the amounts claimed is another approach. Medical billing records aren’t always accurate. Insurers sometimes include bills unrelated to the accident or double-count certain charges. A line-by-line review can identify errors.
For Medicare, the appeal process allows you to contest the claimed amount based on whether Medicare was the primary or secondary payer, whether all listed services are actually related to the accident, and whether the settlement amount justifies full reimbursement.
Medicaid reductions in Florida follow a statutory formula. When an attorney represents you, Florida law caps Medicaid’s recovery at 50% of the total recovery after attorney fees and costs are deducted, or the actual amount Medicaid paid, whichever is less.
How a Lawyer Protects Your Recovery
Handling subrogation claims requires attention to detail and knowledge of both state and federal law. Missing a deadline or failing to properly notify a lienholder can create serious problems.
Attorneys typically place settlement proceeds in a trust account while resolving all liens and claims. This protects everyone’s interests. The insurance company that wants repayment knows the money is secure. You know that all valid claims will be resolved before funds are distributed. And the attorney ensures compliance with professional rules about handling client funds.
An experienced personal injury attorney identifies all potential subrogation claims early in the case. This includes contacting Medicare, reviewing health insurance policies, and checking for Medicaid involvement. Knowing what liens exist helps in evaluating settlement offers and advising you whether an offer fairly compensates you after all deductions.
Negotiating lien reductions is a skill that comes from repeated practice. Attorneys who regularly handle injury cases know which insurers negotiate and which ones don’t. They understand the relevant case law and statutory provisions that support reduction arguments. They know how to document that you weren’t made whole, which strengthens reduction requests.
The attorney also prevents you from accidentally violating subrogation rights. If you settle a case and spend the entire settlement without addressing a Medicare lien, you could face collection actions and federal penalties. An attorney ensures that all parties with valid claims get proper notice and payment.
Reviewing Your Reimbursement Claims Checklist
Before accepting any settlement, review these items:
Obtain written verification of all medical payments from every insurance source. Don’t rely on verbal estimates. Request a detailed accounting of every claim paid, the date of service, the provider, and the amount.
Review your health insurance policy to understand the specific subrogation language. Some policies limit reimbursement rights. Others include attorney fees and cost-sharing provisions.
Determine whether Medicare or Medicaid paid any bills. Both programs maintain online portals where conditional payment amounts can be verified. Request an official demand letter showing exactly what they claim.
Calculate your total damages, including medical bills, lost income, future treatment needs, and pain and suffering. Document why the settlement doesn’t make you whole if that’s the case.
Confirm that every bill on the reimbursement demand actually relates to the accident. Health insurers sometimes include unrelated treatment in their lien demands.
Get proposed reductions in writing before finalizing any settlement. Don’t release settlement funds until you have written agreements from all lienholders confirming reduced amounts.
Understand the timeline for resolving liens. Medicare requires settlement reporting within specific timeframes. Missing deadlines can create problems.
Were You Hurt in an Accident? Let Us Help You
Hurt? Your Journey to Justice Starts Here.
Get Your Free & Confidential Case Review TodayMoving Forward With Confidence
Subrogation claims represent one of the most misunderstood aspects of personal injury settlements. Many accident victims don’t learn about these claims until they’re ready to receive their settlement check, only to discover that much of what they expected to receive will go to insurers instead.
The key is addressing these issues from the start of your case. When you understand how different insurance types interact, which entities have reimbursement rights, and what strategies can reduce those claims, you’re in a much better position to evaluate settlement offers and protect your recovery.
Don’t let surprise subrogation claims reduce your settlement more than necessary. An attorney who handles these claims regularly knows how to spot opportunities for reductions and has the experience to negotiate effectively with Medicare, Medicaid, and private insurers.
Unsure why your settlement seems low? We can help you navigate subrogation. Contact us for a case evaluation that examines not just what you might recover, but what you’ll actually keep after all reimbursement claims are addressed. Understanding the complete picture makes all the difference in knowing whether a settlement offer truly serves your interests.
