Car Accident Demand Letter Response!

Car Accident Demand Letter Response!
Last updated Thursday, January 22nd, 2026

A car accident demand letter response from insurance companies typically arrives within 30 to 60 days of receiving your demand, though timeframes vary based on case complexity and insurer practices. Insurers must acknowledge demand letters promptly, usually within 15 days, though comprehensive responses require claim file review, medical record analysis, liability assessment, and settlement authority approval.

itial responses often request additional documentation or clarification about damages, treatment, or accident circumstances. Common response types include full settlement offers accepting liability and offering compensation, though usually less than demanded; partial offers acknowledging some liability but disputing damage amounts or causation; denials rejecting liability entirely and refusing compensation; and reservation of rights letters neither accepting nor denying claims while continuing investigation.

When evaluating responses, compare offers against your documented damages, considering whether amounts adequately compensate medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and future needs. Lowball initial offers are common negotiation tactics; don’t accept first offers without thorough evaluation. Insufficient offers require counter-demands supported by additional evidence, medical opinions, or legal arguments.

If insurers deny claims or make unreasonable offers, consider formal complaints to state insurance departments or litigation. Response timing affects negotiations; quick responses may indicate clear liability and settlement willingness, while delayed responses might signal disputed liability or investigation complexity.

Throughout negotiations, maintain documentation of all communications, continue medical treatment as prescribed, and avoid recorded statements or signed releases without attorney consultation. Most cases require multiple negotiation rounds before reaching fair settlements.

Related Article(s)

American Association of Justice badge Bar Register badge Top 25 Trial Lawyers badge Civil Trial badge Verified Member of Best of the Bar -- 2020-2025 badge Florida Bar badge Best Law Firms 2024 badge Legal Elite badge PBCBA badge Top 100 Trial Lawyers badge LCA Fellow badge